From janshep@watson.ibm.com Mon Nov 27 20:40:26 1995 Received: from watson.ibm.com (watson.ibm.com [129.34.139.4]) by dkuug.dk (8.6.12/8.6.12) with SMTP id UAA23400 for ; Mon, 27 Nov 1995 20:40:22 +0100 Message-Id: <199511271940.UAA23400@dkuug.dk> Received: from YKTVMV by watson.ibm.com (IBM VM SMTP V2R3) with BSMTP id 9987; Mon, 27 Nov 95 14:39:51 EST Date: Mon, 27 Nov 95 14:37:45 EST From: "Janice C. Shepherd ((914) 784-6313)" X-Addr: J1-K10, Hawthorne 2 tieline 863 To: sc22wg5@dkuug.dk Subject: 006 ballot I encourage everyone to participate in this ballot. Mallory: please include this in the premeeting for meeting 136. Thanks. Janice -------------------------------------------------------------- To:X3J3 From: Janice Shepherd Subject: 006 post-meeting 135 letter ballot This is the 006 post-meeting 135 letter ballot. The ballot looks a little different from other 006 post-meeting ballots as it includes votes for edits being applied to Fortran 95. Some of the 006 items listed below include edits to the Fortran 90 standard. If these 006 items are approved then corresponding edits to Fortran 95 may be needed to keep the two standards synchronized. Thus this ballot includes votes on the proposed Fortran 95 edits. The proposed edits use page/line numbers from the CD version of Fortran 95 (95-007r1). If you decide to vote No on a defect item that contains an edit, please indicate in your comment whether you approve of the edit for Fortran 90. (ie your NO vote is based on the text in the answer/discussion not on the edit). Approving the edit will mean that the edit can be included in corrigendum 3, even though work is still needed on the text of the defect item. This ballot is being conducted by email. No hardcopy will be mailed. Please respond by e-mail. If you are unable to respond by e-mail please contact me (Janice Shepherd (1-914-784-6313)). Please let me know if you have any concerns about the ballot. The ballot will end at midnight (eastern time) Jan 2nd. This is longer than 30 days to give time for holidays/vacations. The text of the defect items and the F95 edits were sent out separately. Let me know if you did not receive the items. Please do NOT return the text of the defect items when voting. If you want to make a comment about an interpretation (you must make a comment if you are voting No) please put the comment in the following format: number vote lastname Comment text .... more comment .... eg. 0 Y Bleikamp I really like these edits! This format makes it easier for me to sort the comments by interpretation number. As I won't be sorting the comments on the F95 edits, I'm not recommending a specific style for them. You do not have to use the ballot form listed below to indicate your vote. Sending me a note indicating "I vote yes without comments on all items except for the following ..." is an acceptable form of voting. Other forms of voting are fine too, as long as I can understand your vote. Janice Shepherd/voice: (914) 784-6313 fax: (914) 784-6306 To reply by email mail to janshep@watson.ibm.com ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Y|wc N 95-006 Item or Fortran 95 edit |_|_| |_| 000027 Requirements for pointer and target association |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 27 |_|_| |_| 000081 Pointer actual argument overlap |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 81 |_|_| |_| 000100 ASSOCIATED intrinsic and zero-sized objects |_|_| |_| 000125 Copy in/copy out of target dummy arguments |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 125 |_|_| |_| 000145 Expressions in of a FUNCTION statement |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 145 |_|_| |_| 000148 RANDOM_SEED, RANDOM_NUMBER |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 148 |_|_| |_| 000154 EQUIVALENCE and zero-sized sequences |_|_| |_| 000155 Multiple USE statements, rename and only lists. |_|_| |_| 000176 Definition of RANDOM_SEED |_|_| |_| 000179 DO variable with POINTER attribute |_|_| |_| 000183 Unambiguous procedure overloading |_|_| |_| 000185 What is the allocation status of an array after an allocation failure? |_|_| |_| 000187 TARGET attribute, storage association, and pointer ass. |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 187 |_|_| |_| 000194 Statements between SELECT CASE and CASE |_|_| |_| 000196 Inaccessibility of intrinsic procedures |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 196 |_|_| |_| 000201 SELECTED_REAL_KIND result |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 201 |_|_| |_| 000203 Scope of operator/assignment symbols |_|_| |_| Fortran 95 edits listed for defect item 203