From JANSHEP@torolab2.vnet.ibm.com Wed Jan 11 09:06:10 1995 Received: from vnet.ibm.com by dkuug.dk with SMTP id AA21631 (5.65c8/IDA-1.4.4j for ); Wed, 11 Jan 1995 20:06:42 +0100 Message-Id: <199501111906.AA21631@dkuug.dk> Received: from TOROLAB2 by VNET.IBM.COM (IBM VM SMTP V2R2) with BSMTP id 2723; Wed, 11 Jan 95 14:06:25 EST Date: Wed, 11 Jan 95 14:06:10 EST From: "Janice Shepherd" To: sc22wg5@dkuug.dk, jtm@llnl.gov Subject: informal 006 ballot X-Charset: ASCII X-Char-Esc: 29 Here is my ballot. Janice Shepherd === WG5 informal letter ballot on N1070 items.....closing date Jan. 13, 1995 === The titles of the 17 items are listed below, "Y" indicates the "Yes" column (without comments), "wc" next to "Y" represents the "Yes-with-comments" column, and "N" indicates the "No" column. Comments or reasons may be inserted after each item or listed following the ballot. An acceptable electronic response might be simply "Yes on all items" or "Yes on all items except ..." It is not necessary to return the ballot below in this case. To supply a comment or a reason for a no vote, please use the following format: number vote lastname (or country) text For example: 28 Y Martin In the discussion, replace "local implicitly typed scalar" with "local, implicitly-typed scalar" This helps with sorting the results. Electronic responses to the ballot are preferred, but fax and post are acceptable so long as they meet the deadline of Jan. 13, 1995. This deadline was chosen in order that the results could be available for the 132nd X3J3 meeting. Y|wc N N1070 Item |x|_| |_| 000028 Host association and Implicit type rules |_|x| |_| 000030 Length of character literals in array constructors 30 Y Shepherd It would be nice if the quote from the standard (just after the first example) could be indented and put in quotes. |x|_| |_| 000041 Procedure with target dummy argument requires explicit interface |x|_| |_| 000049 Characteristics of function results |_|x| |_| 000086 USE and host association 86 Y Shepherd There appear to be a few extra blanks: In the Question section (before the numbered questions) "named entities" -> "named entities" "derived types" -> "derived types" In answer 6 "of interfaces" -> "of interfaces" "recursive application" -> "recursive application" (twice) |x|_| |_| 000100 ASSOCIATED intrinsic and zero-sized objects |x|_| |_| 000121 ";" As a Statement Separator |_|_| |X| 000129 Array constructors in initialization expressions N 129 Shepherd This is too big a change to be making at this time. There is no indication that the extra features were intended when the standard was developed. This change should be left to Fortran 95. |_|x| |_| 000135 INTENT(IN) conformance Y 135 Shepherd John Reid's proposed new wording of the edit sounds fine. |x|_| |_| 000137 array-element in data-implied-do |x|_| |_| 000139 INTRINSIC, EXTERNAL attribute questions |x|_| |_| 000143 Use association and functions/subroutines/intrinsics |_|x| |_| 000147 Generic name resolution 147 Y Shepherd "CSQRT(16) is according to 14.1.2.4.2 to " -> "CSQRT(16) is, according to 14.1.2.4.2, to " -> |x|_| |_| 000177 Structures in EQUIVALENCE lists |_|x| |_| 000179 DO variable with POINTER attribute 179 Y Shepherd Uppercase the texts of the examples In the discussion "It was an oversight to prohibit ..." I believe what we meant was "It was an oversight to not prohibit ..." |x|_| |_| 000181 stop-code in STOP and PAUSE statements |_|x| |_| 000182 Intrinsics in statement functions Y 182 Shepherd John Reid's proposed new wording of the edit sounds fine.